Law and Democracy Support Foundation and the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms Document Medical Neglect, Denial of Exercise and Adequate Food, and False Official Claims That He Waived His Right to Legal Counsel
Law and Democracy Support Foundation (LDSF) and the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms (ECRF) express their grave concern over the continued deterioration of the health condition of writer and novelist Peter Tawfik Kamal, and his ongoing deprivation of liberty in connection with Case No. 1184 of 2026 (Mallawi Administrative Police Station Case), ahead of the detention renewal hearing scheduled for Tuesday, 17 November 2026. In this case, Peter faces charges including “contempt of religion” and “leading and organizing a group allegedly aimed at promoting atheism, denigrating revealed religions, and inciting sectarian strife.”The two organizations believe that Peter Tawfik’s continued detention under harsh conditions, coupled with the denial of adequate medical care and fundamental fair trial guarantees, constitutes not only a violation of his individual rights but also raises serious concerns regarding his safety, health, and human dignity. His continued detention also comes amid a troubling climate of increasing restrictions on freedom of thought and creativity, and the criminalization of peaceful expression and literary production, with serious repercussions for Egypt’s cultural and intellectual landscape.According to documented information obtained by the two organizations, Peter Tawfik’s health condition has significantly deteriorated in recent weeks. He suffered from a severe fever caused by an abscess on his back while being deprived of the medical care necessary to address his condition. The harsh conditions of detention have further aggravated his health problems, as detainees are reportedly denied exercise and remain confined inside detention facilities for prolonged periods. They are also forced to sleep in unsuitable conditions without adequate blankets, resulting in a noticeable decline in Peter’s physical health and significant weight loss.The two organizations have also received information indicating increasing restrictions on the entry of Peter’s basic necessities. The frequency with which food may be brought to him has reportedly been reduced, while numerous food items and fruits have been denied entry. Books and blankets have likewise been prohibited. On 12 November 2026, the administration of Mallawi Prison refused to allow his medication to be delivered to him. The medication was only permitted to enter the prison after objections were raised to the decision and a formal complaint was threatened.These practices are inconsistent with Article 55 of the Egyptian Constitution, which guarantees the dignity of all individuals who are arrested or detained and requires detention facilities to meet humane and health standards. They are also contrary to the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules), which guarantee detainees’ rights to adequate healthcare, sufficient nutrition, appropriate sleeping accommodations, and regular exercise.In a related development, the two organizations received statements from Peter’s legal defense team indicating that the authorities claimed during a previous detention renewal hearing that Peter had refused to be represented by a lawyer. The defense team categorically denied this allegation, affirming that he has consistently insisted on exercising his right to legal counsel and on the presence of his lawyers during all legal proceedings related to the case. This incident constitutes a serious violation of the right to defense and the right to a fair trial, both of which are guaranteed under the Egyptian Constitution and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).Security forces detained Peter on 14 April 2026 after summoning him to a facility belonging to the National Security Agency in Minya Governorate. He was not brought before the Public Prosecution until 22 April 2026, after eight days of complete isolation from his family and lawyers, a period during which he was subjected to enforced disappearance. During the subsequent investigations, Peter requested access to specialized medical care due to his diagnosis of bipolar disorder and his need for regular treatment and psychiatric follow-up.The two organizations emphasize that prosecuting a writer or novelist for literary works or ideas expressed peacefully constitutes a serious infringement on freedom of expression and artistic and literary freedom, rights protected under both the Egyptian Constitution and international human rights standards. Creative works should be the subject of discussion, critique, and public debate, not grounds for punishment or deprivation of liberty.The consequences of these violations extend beyond Peter Tawfik himself. They send a chilling message to writers, artists, intellectuals, and all individuals exercising their right to express opinions, thereby reinforcing a climate of self-censorship and narrowing the space available for creativity and free thought. Depriving a writer of liberty, holding him in harsh conditions of detention, and denying him access to books, an essential part of both his life and profession, constitute an attack not only on his personal and professional rights but also on society’s broader right to intellectual and cultural pluralism.In light of the above, Law and Democracy Support Foundation and the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms call on the Egyptian authorities to: Immediately and unconditionally release writer and novelist Peter Tawfik Kamal and drop all charges stemming from his peaceful exercise of his rights to freedom of thought, expression, and creative activity. Ensure, without delay, access to adequate healthcare, including examination by an independent specialized psychiatrist, and guarantee his access to necessary treatment, medication, and regular medical follow-up.Immediately cease all forms of harassment and ill-treatment against him, and ensure his regular access to daily exercise, as well as the unhindered entry of medication, books, blankets, food, and other essential necessities.Guarantee full respect for his right to defense and a fair trial, including ensuring that his legal team can attend all hearings and proceedings and access the case file without restriction.Conduct an independent, impartial, and effective investigation into all violations he has suffered, including his enforced disappearance, the conditions of his detention, the denial of medical care, and violations of his defense rights, and hold those responsible accountable. End the use of pretrial detention in cases involving peaceful expression and literary or artistic production, and ensure that judicial practices comply with the Egyptian Constitution and Egypt’s international obligations concerning freedom of opinion, expression, and creativity. The two organizations stress that protecting artistic and literary freedom is not merely a legal obligation but a fundamental prerequisite for a healthy public sphere in which ideas can be freely exchanged and openly debated. They further emphasize that the continued detention of Peter Tawfik despite the deterioration of his health places direct responsibility on the Egyptian authorities for his physical and psychological well-being and underscores the urgent need for his immediate release without delay.
